Your Cart is Empty
Rediscover the Magic of Original Ty Beanie Babies
Step back into the 90s with our curated collection of Retired Ty Beanie Babies. At Chickenmash Farm, we specialize in authentic vintage plush and rare collectibles hand-picked from auctions across Ohio. Whether you are looking for a first-generation favorite or a rare "error" tag, our rotating selection is a treasure hunt for collectors of all ages.
Our Collection Highlights:
- Retired Classics: Original favorites like and .
- Mint Condition Finds: Many of our beanies are "MWMT" (Mint with Mint Tags) and feature original heart tags in protective covers.
- Nostalgic Gifts: The perfect surprise for 90s kids or a special addition to a farmhouse gallery wall.
Hand-Picked in Ohio
Every Beanie Baby in our shop is an authentic heritage find. We check every tush tag and heart tag to ensure you’re getting a genuine piece of toy history.
Every Beanie Baby in our shop is an authentic heritage find. We check every tush tag and heart tag to ensure you’re getting a genuine piece of toy history.
Explore our latest Beanie Baby arrivals and find your favorite today!
