Free standard shipping for domestic orders over $59 with promo code FREESHIP

Menu
0

Free standard shipping for domestic orders over $59 with promo code FREESHIP

    0

    Your Cart is Empty

  • Main menu
  • Home / Toys for All Ages, New Plush & Gently Used Kids Toys | Chickenmash Farm

    Toys for kids and babies at great prices.

    toy collection
    A Toy Box Full of Wonders for Every Generation
    Welcome to the complete toy collection at Chickenmash Farm, where we believe playtime has no age limit! Our curated selection is a "treasure hunt" of new plush animals, gently used kids' toys, and nostalgic retro collectibles. Whether you are shopping for a newborn’s first security blanket or a rare 90s classic for a dedicated collector, you’ll find it here.
    Something for Everyone:
    • New Plush & Stuffed Animals: Soft, huggable companions ready for a new home.
    • Gently Used & Pre-Loved Toys: Quality-checked treasures that are perfect for sustainable gifting and affordable play.
    • Retro & Vintage Finds: A rotating selection of Ty Beanie Babies and 80s/90s nostalgia sourced from local Ohio auctions.
    • Nursery & Baby Gifts: Unique, charming pieces that add character to any child's room.
    Sustainable Play from Our Ohio Farm
    By offering a mix of new and "rescued" toys, we provide a more sustainable way to shop for the little ones in your life. Every item is hand-inspected at our Williamsport farm to ensure it’s ready for its next adventure.
    Browse our full collection today and find a one-of-a-kind gift that sparks joy!
    Ty Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Chip the Cat 1999
    Ty Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Chip the Cat 1999 $ 3.00 $ 5.00
    Sale
    TY Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Strut The Rooster
    TY Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Strut The Rooster $ 3.00 $ 5.00
    Sale
    TY Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy Meal Toy 1999 Stretchy The Ostrich
    TY Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy Meal Toy 1999 Stretchy The Ostrich $ 3.00 $ 5.00
    Sale
    Boyds Bear Bailey Plush Christmas Bear Bailey & Friends Collection 8"
    Boyds Bear Bailey Plush Christmas Bear Bailey & Friends Collection 8" $ 20.00
    Ty Attic Treasures Collection Wee Willie Bear 1993 8 Inch
    Ty Attic Treasures Collection Wee Willie Bear 1993 8 Inch $ 5.00
    Ty Beanie Babies Hippity Hoppity Floppity Retired Rabbits 1996
    Ty Beanie Babies Hippity Hoppity Floppity Retired Rabbits 1996 $ 59.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Hippity the Rabbit 1996 Green Rabbit
    Ty Beanie Baby Hippity the Rabbit 1996 Green Rabbit $ 25.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Fuzz the Bear 1998
    Ty Beanie Baby Fuzz the Bear 1998 $ 15.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Rocket the Blue Jay 1997
    Ty Beanie Baby Rocket the Blue Jay 1997 $ 8.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Halo the Bear Angel with Brown Nose 1998
    Ty Beanie Baby Halo the Bear Angel with Brown Nose 1998 $ 23.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Gracie the Swan 1996
    Ty Beanie Baby Gracie the Swan 1996 $ 6.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Addison the Baseball Bear 2001
    Ty Beanie Baby Addison the Baseball Bear 2001 $ 6.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Ringo the Racoon 1995
    Ty Beanie Baby Ringo the Racoon 1995 $ 6.00
    Beak the Kiwi Birds Beanie Baby Beanie Buddy 2 Piece Set
    Beak the Kiwi Birds Beanie Baby Beanie Buddy 2 Piece Set $ 30.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Honks the Goose 1999
    Ty Beanie Baby Honks the Goose 1999 $ 10.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Puffer the Puffin 1997
    Ty Beanie Baby Puffer the Puffin 1997 $ 8.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Zero the Penguin with Santa Hat 1998
    Ty Beanie Baby Zero the Penguin with Santa Hat 1998 $ 8.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Crunch the Shark 1996 Style 4130
    Ty Beanie Baby Crunch the Shark 1996 Style 4130 $ 8.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Bessie the Cow Style 4009 1995
    Ty Beanie Baby Bessie the Cow Style 4009 1995 $ 8.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Kuku the Cockatoo Bird
    Ty Beanie Baby Kuku the Cockatoo Bird $ 8.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Roam the Buffalo Brown Buffalo
    Ty Beanie Baby Roam the Buffalo Brown Buffalo
    Sold Out
    Sold out
    Ty Beanie Baby Trumpet the Elephant 2000
    Ty Beanie Baby Trumpet the Elephant 2000 $ 8.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Niles the Camel 2000
    Ty Beanie Baby Niles the Camel 2000 $ 8.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Mel the Koala Bear 1996
    Ty Beanie Baby Mel the Koala Bear $ 6.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Osito Mexican Bear 1999
    Ty Beanie Baby Osito Mexican Bear 1999 $ 20.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Ty 2K Bear 2000 Y2K Bear
    Ty Beanie Baby Ty 2K Bear 2000 Y2K Bear $ 20.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Curly the Bear 1996
    Ty Beanie Baby Curly the Bear 1996 $ 8.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Flitter the Butterfly 1999
    Ty Beanie Baby Flitter the Butterfly 1999 $ 12.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Spooky the Ghost Style 4090
    Ty Beanie Baby Spooky the Ghost Style 4090 $ 8.00
    Ty Collectible The Attic Treasures Collection Casanova Bear 1993
    Ty Collectible The Attic Treasures Collection Casanova Bear 1993 $ 10.00
    Ty Beanie Baby 1999 Holiday Teddy the Bear
    Ty Beanie Baby 1999 Holiday Teddy the Bear $ 10.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Nibbler the Rabbit 1998
    Ty Beanie Baby Nibbler the Rabbit 1998 $ 8.00
    TY Beanie Baby Scaly the Lizard 1999
    TY Beanie Baby Scaly the Lizard 1999 $ 8.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Freckles the Leopard Style 4066
    Ty Beanie Baby Freckles the Leopard Style 4066 $ 8.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Strut the Rooster 1996
    Ty Beanie Baby Strut the Rooster 1996 $ 8.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Tracker the Bassett Hound 1997/1998
    Ty Beanie Baby Tracker the Bassett Hound 1997/1998 $ 15.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Iggy the Iguana Tie Dye No Tongue
    Ty Beanie Baby Iggy the Iguana Tie Dye No Tongue $ 15.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Tie Dye Iggy the Iguana with Tongue 1997
    Ty Beanie Baby Tie Dye Iggy the Iguana with Tongue 1997 $ 15.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Stretch the Ostrich
    Ty Beanie Baby Stretch the Ostrich 1997 $ 10.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Rainbow the Blue Chameleon 1997
    Ty Beanie Baby Rainbow the Blue Chameleon 1997 $ 10.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Waddle the Penguin 1995 Style 4075
    Ty Beanie Baby Waddle the Penguin 1995 Style 4075 $ 8.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Chipper the Chipmunk Plush Toy 1999
    Ty Beanie Baby Chipper the Chipmunk Plush Toy
    Sold Out
    Sold out
    Ty Beanie Baby Mystic the Unicorn Iridescent Horn Coarse Mane
    Ty Beanie Baby Mystic the Unicorn Iridescent Horn Coarse Mane $ 6.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Bruno the Dog 1997
    Ty Beanie Baby Bruno the Dog 1997 $ 8.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Squealer the Pig plush pig
    Ty Beanie Baby Squealer the Pig $ 30.00
    TY Beanie Baby Chip the Cat
    TY Beanie Baby Chip the Cat $ 15.00
    Butch the dog Beanie Baby
    TY Beanie Baby Butch the Bull Terrier 1998
    Sold Out
    Sold out
    TY Beanie Baby 1997 Holiday Teddy the Bear Style 4200
    TY Beanie Baby 1997 Holiday Teddy the Bear Style 4200 $ 20.00
    Load More Products