Free standard shipping for domestic orders over $59 with promo code FREESHIP

Menu
0

Free standard shipping for domestic orders over $59 with promo code FREESHIP

    0

    Your Cart is Empty

  • Main menu
  • Home / Toys for All Ages, New Plush & Gently Used Kids Toys | Chickenmash Farm

    Toys for kids and babies at great prices.

    toy collection
    A Toy Box Full of Wonders for Every Generation
    Welcome to the complete toy collection at Chickenmash Farm, where we believe playtime has no age limit! Our curated selection is a "treasure hunt" of new plush animals, gently used kids' toys, and nostalgic retro collectibles. Whether you are shopping for a newborn’s first security blanket or a rare 90s classic for a dedicated collector, you’ll find it here.
    Something for Everyone:
    • New Plush & Stuffed Animals: Soft, huggable companions ready for a new home.
    • Gently Used & Pre-Loved Toys: Quality-checked treasures that are perfect for sustainable gifting and affordable play.
    • Retro & Vintage Finds: A rotating selection of Ty Beanie Babies and 80s/90s nostalgia sourced from local Ohio auctions.
    • Nursery & Baby Gifts: Unique, charming pieces that add character to any child's room.
    Sustainable Play from Our Ohio Farm
    By offering a mix of new and "rescued" toys, we provide a more sustainable way to shop for the little ones in your life. Every item is hand-inspected at our Williamsport farm to ensure it’s ready for its next adventure.
    Browse our full collection today and find a one-of-a-kind gift that sparks joy!
    Ty Beanie Baby Sly the Fox 1996
    Ty Beanie Baby Sly the Fox 1996 $ 6.00
    Robin Woods Doll Courtney Christmas 1985 American Children Collection 22in
    Robin Woods Doll Courtney Christmas 1985 American Children Collection 22in $ 49.00
    Robin Woods Hope Collectible Doll 1989 14inch This Is My Country Doll
    Robin Woods Hope Collectible Doll 1989 14inch This Is My Country Doll $ 50.00
    2017 Burger King Angry Birds Red Terrence Bird Figure Toy
    2017 Burger King Angry Birds Red Terrence Bird Figure Toy $ 5.00
    Robin Woods Little Orphan Annie Doll Collectible 14in Doll 1986
    Robin Woods Little Orphan Annie Doll Collectible 14in Doll 1986 $ 35.00
    Engel Puppen Plush Vinyl Doll 12 Inch Doll Made In Germany
    Engel Puppen Plush Vinyl Doll 12 Inch Doll Made In Germany $ 10.00
    Precious Moments Dolls of the Month December by Applause
    Precious Moments Dolls of the Month December by Applause
    Sold Out
    Sold out
    Precious Moments Dolls of the Month Angie December Applause
    Precious Moments Dolls of the Month Angie December Applause
    Sold Out
    Sold out
    Precious Moments Dolls of the Month March Applause
    Precious Moments Dolls of the Month March Applause $ 8.00
    Transformers Autobot Sqweeks RC by Hasbro The Last Knight Robot
    Transformers Autobot Sqweeks RC by Hasbro The Last Knight Robot $ 30.00
    Disneys Beauty and the Beast Enchanted Christmas Belle Doll 1997
    Disneys Beauty and the Beast Enchanted Christmas Belle Doll 1997 $ 35.00
    Ty Scat The Cat Beanie Baby 1999 Cat Stuffed Animal
    Ty Scat The Cat Beanie Baby 1999 Cat Stuffed Animal $ 8.00
    McDonalds Ty Beanie Baby Erin the Bear Irish Bear 1999
    McDonalds Ty Beanie Baby Erin the Bear Irish Bear 1999 $ 10.00
    McDonalds Ty Beanie Baby Britannia the Bear Great Britain 1999
    McDonalds Ty Beanie Baby Britannia the Bear Great Britain 1999 $ 10.00
    McDonalds Ty Beanie Baby Maple the Bear Canada Unopened 1999
    McDonalds Ty Beanie Baby Maple the Bear Canada Unopened 1999 $ 10.00
    Disney Aladdin Holiday Princess Jasmine 1999 4th Edition Series
    Disney Aladdin Holiday Princess Jasmine 1999 4th Edition Series $ 30.00
    Despicable Me Minion Figures Mineez Toy 3-Pack
    Despicable Me Minion Figures Mineez Toy 3-Pack $ 8.00
    TY Beanie Baby Smoochy the Frog Collectible Plush 1997
    TY Beanie Baby Smoochy the Frog Collectible Plush 1997 $ 8.00
    Hallmark Plush Bunny Rabbit 9in Stuffed Animal White
    Hallmark Plush Bunny Rabbit 9in Stuffed Animal White $ 6.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Snowball the Snowman Style 4201
    Ty Beanie Baby Snowball the Snowman Style 4201 $ 10.00
    Ty Beanie Baby Hope Bear Praying Bear 1998
    Ty Beanie Baby Hope Bear Praying Bear 1998 $ 10.00
    Disney Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs Enchanted Princess Doll 2000
    Disney Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs Enchanted Princess Doll 2000 $ 60.00
    Disney Holiday Collection Snow White Holiday Princess Doll 1998
    Disney Holiday Collection Snow White Holiday Princess Doll 1998 $ 25.00
    Robin Woods Plush Stuffed Bear Princess Brown Stuffed Animal 1988
    Robin Woods Plush Stuffed Bear Princess Brown Stuffed Animal 1988 $ 18.00
    Pittsburgh Originals Robin Woods Vinyl Doll 14in Clown Doll Stardust 1988
    Pittsburgh Originals Robin Woods Vinyl Doll 14" Clown Doll Stardust 1988 $ 23.00
    Dan Dee Collector's Choice Snowflake Teddy 2007 Plush Brown Bear 20in
    Dan Dee Collector's Choice Snowflake Teddy 2007 Plush Brown Bear 20in $ 16.00
    Ty Beanie Babies Booties The Cat Black And White Plush Cat 2002
    Ty Beanie Babies Booties The Cat Black And White Plush Cat 2002
    Sold Out
    Sold out
    G.A.C. Vintage Reindeer Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 1999
    G.A.C. Vintage Reindeer Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 1999
    Sold Out
    Sold out
    The Original Holy Bear United Methodist Church White Bear Red Ribbon Bow
    The Original Holy Bears United Methodist Church White Bear Red Ribbon Bow
    Sold Out
    Sold out
    Sunny Toys German Plush Bear Stuffed Animal 6 Inch
    Sunny Toys German Plush Bear Stuffed Animal 6 Inch $ 8.00
    Studio 33 Plush Bunny Rabbit 9" Stuffed Animal 1998
    Studio 33 Plush Bunny Rabbit 9" Stuffed Animal 1998 $ 10.00
    Boyds Bear Bestest & Buddy Truefriends
    Boyds Bear Bestest & Buddy Truefriends $ 8.00
    First & Main Plush Teddy Bear Scraggles With Heart Sweater
    First & Main Plush Teddy Bear Scraggles With Heart Sweater $ 8.00
    Audrey Porcelain Doll Purple Dress With Umbrella
    Audrey Porcelain Doll Purple Dress With Umbrella $ 99.00
    Louis Nichole Porcelain Collectible Doll 24 Inch Doll 1997
    Louis Nichole Porcelain Collectible Doll 24" Doll 1997 $ 120.00
    Engel Puppe Doll Dorothea Made In Germany Doll
    Engel Puppe Doll Dorothea Made In Germany Doll $ 99.00
    Goebel Carol Ann Doll 9.5 inch Doll With Stand Brown Hair 1992
    Goebel Carol Ann Doll 9.5" Doll With Stand Brown Hair 1992 $ 9.00
    Boots Tyner Reproduction Weighted Body Doll With Glasses 1987
    Boots Tyner Reproduction Weighted Body Doll With Glasses 1987 $ 22.00
    Plush Teddy Bear with Calico Print Dress 10" Jointed Bear Plush Toy
    Plush Teddy Bear with Calico Print Dress 10" Jointed Bear Plush Toy $ 5.00
    Ty Beanie Baby McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Smoochy the Frog 1999
    Ty Beanie Baby McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Smoochy the Frog 1999 $ 3.00 $ 6.00
    Sale
    Ty Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Nook the Husky 1999
    Ty Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Nook the Husky 1999 $ 3.00 $ 5.00
    Sale
    Ty Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Iggy the Iguana 1999
    Ty Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Iggy the Iguana 1999 $ 3.00 $ 6.00
    Sale
    Ty Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Spunky the Cocker Spaniel
    Ty Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Spunky the Cocker Spaniel $ 3.00 $ 5.00
    Sale
    Ty Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Antsy the Anteater1999
    Ty Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Antsy the Anteater1999 $ 3.00 $ 5.00
    Sale
    Ty Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Freckles the Leopard 1999
    Ty Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Freckles the Leopard 1999 $ 3.00 $ 5.00
    Sale
    Ty Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Nuts the Squirrel
    Ty Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Nuts the Squirrel $ 3.00 $ 5.00
    Sale
    Ty Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Rocket the Blue Jay
    Ty Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Rocket the Blue Jay $ 3.00 $ 5.00
    Sale
    Ty Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy meal Toy 1999 Claude the Crab
    Ty Beanie Babies McDonalds Happy meal Toy 1999 Claude the Crab $ 3.00 $ 5.00
    Sale
    Load More Products